Wednesday, October 5, 2011

Should I bring a pen along?

Last August I wrote about documents I received through an open records request for documents related to No Refusal Weekends in Harris County. See herehere, here and here.

Today it's time to take a trip down the Gulf Freeway to the island to what Galveston County officials have been up to when it comes to making a mockery out of the Fourth Amendment.
June 27, 2011 - 
"Special Crimes Prosecutor Bill Reed has coordinated preparations for this event, which will take place in Galveston County this Friday, Saturday and Sunday nights from 8 pm through 4 am at the Dickinson Police Department. (Special thanks go to Chief Morales for his hospitality.) Bill has enlisted the cooperation of Judges Lonnie Cox, John Ellisor and Christopher Dupuy to approve and sign the blood search warrants, as well as nurses who will be present and ready to make the blood draws." 
-- Galveston County District Attorney Jack Roady (group e-mail)
The DA's Office has "enlisted the cooperation" of judges to "approve and sign" search warrants authorizing blood draws. As I have stated many times before, if the state is "enlisting" judges to participate in this spectacle, the deck is already stacked against anyone accused of driving while intoxicated. And, yes, that Christopher Dupuy.

Hmmm... how might that conversation go?

Prosecutor: "Judge, I was wondering if you'd like to volunteer to approve and sign search warrants for blood draws during our No Refusal Weekend?"

Judge: "Ordering a blood draw on a misdemeanor case? That's insane."


Prosecutor: "I'll take that as a no. Next!"
August 31, 2011 - 
"Special Crimes Prosecutor Bill Reed has coordinated for this event, which will take place in Galveston County this Friday, Saturday and Sunday nights from 11 pm through 4 am at the Dickinson Police Department. Bill has enlisted the cooperation of Judges John Ellisor, Christopher Dupuy and John Grady to approve and sign the blood search warrants, as well as nurses who will be present and ready to make the blood draws." 
-- Galveston County District Attorney Jack Roady (group e-mail)
Please note, no one is talking about reviewing warrant applications. The judges are there to approve the warrants and subject motorists to an intrusive procedure. This is limited government? Oh, now I understand, they were talking about limiting the authority the judiciary has over the police, not the authority of the state over the individual. That makes so much more sense now.

An application for a search warrant should be reviewed by a neutral and detached magistrate. Once a judge accepts the pitch from the DA to be a part of the team for a No Refusal Weekend, that judge loses any claim to being detached. Either he was asked to participate or he volunteered - either way, the judge is far from neutral.

And despite "fill in the blank" warrant applications that are long on conclusions and woefully short on facts, these "neutral and detached" judges are more than happy to take pen to paper to authorize the shredding of the last remnants of the constitution.

No comments: