A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed. -- 2nd Amendment
In the wake of the latest school shooting, I must ask, once again, why is the 2nd Amendment considered so sacrosanct?
The 1st Amendment states that "Congress shall make no law... abridging the freedom of speech." Subsequent constitutional jurisprudence extended this prohibition to the states under the 14th Amendment.
Yet we have plenty of laws that restrict the right to free speech. If you threaten to cause bodily harm to another you have committed a criminal act. If you spread a falsehood about another person you have committed a tort. During World War I you could be arrested if you dared to speak out against the war effort.
The 4th Amendment is supposed to protect us from unreasonable search and seizure. That language was interpreted by the courts to mean the police had to have a warrant to search you, your belongings or your property. As I've said many times before, the 4th Amendment has had so many exceptions cut out of it that it resembles a piece of swiss cheese. In almost every one of those decisions, the Supreme Court created an exception so they wouldn't have to overturn a conviction.
The 5th Amendment says you cannot be compelled to be a witness against yourself. In the context of a DWI case, your refusal to consent to field sobriety exercises or to a breath test can be used as evidence of your guilt at trial. Courts have also done their part in narrowly defining what could be considered testimony, saying an arrest isn't an arrest when it suits the police or prosecution and what the magic words are that a suspect has to utter to preserve his right to remain silent.
For most of our history, the 2nd Amendment was viewed in the context of its first clause, the so-called "militia clause." It wasn't until the late 1970's that the NRA (which supported strengthening gun control measures after the Black Panthers started carrying guns), began touting the 2nd Amendment as an individual right. In fact, the first case that struck down a gun control measure was the Heller case in 2008.
Is the abridged version of the 2nd Amendment held up for adulation more than any of the other amendments because it's not protecting a right of the citizen accused? Does that someone make it more worthy than the others?
The notion that one amendment is sacrosanct while the others are all malleable flies in the face of this country's jurisprudence. It even flies in the face of laws currently on the books. It's against the law for a convicted felon to own a firearm. It's against the law for a person convicted of domestic violence to possess a firearm.
Now I'm not going to sit here and say that stricter gun control measures could have prevented any of the recent school shootings. I also agree with the sentiment that making something illegal doesn't make it go away. But we don't repeal murder laws because folks keep killing each other. I do believe that we need to figure out what it is at the core of our national psyche that makes us the killing machines that we are. We are, at our core, a sick group of people and until we find a cure for the illness, the shootings will continue.
But we need to get past this (recent) notion that the 2nd Amendment is somehow more important than the others. Until then the shootings will continue.
These are the musings, ramblings, rantings and observations of Houston DWI Attorney Paul B. Kennedy on DWI defense, general criminal defense, philosophy and whatever else tickles his fancy.
Showing posts with label 2nd Amendment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2nd Amendment. Show all posts
Friday, May 25, 2018
Thursday, February 22, 2018
Boobies are worse than school shootings
On February 21, 2018, students from Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School traveled to the state capitol in Tallahassee, Florida demanding action on guns.
The legislative session began with a prayer for the victims and survivors of the shooting. This should have served as foreshadowing of what was to happen.
Rep. Kionne McGhee, a Democrat, introduced a bill to ban assault weapons and large capacity ammunition magazines. The bill was brought to the floor for debate on Wednesday.
However, by a vote of 71-36, legislators voted not to debate the bill and it wasn't considered. So, even though there was a majority who would vote the bill down, those opposed to the bill didn't want to risk a public debate on the merits of it. And they had the gall to do it when the students who survived the shooting were in attendance.
But, not to despair, the legislature did vote for a bill to declare pornography a public health risk.
That's Florida for you. Where boobies are bad but guns are good. In other words, in Florida, the 2nd Amendment trumps all.
The legislative session began with a prayer for the victims and survivors of the shooting. This should have served as foreshadowing of what was to happen.
Rep. Kionne McGhee, a Democrat, introduced a bill to ban assault weapons and large capacity ammunition magazines. The bill was brought to the floor for debate on Wednesday.
However, by a vote of 71-36, legislators voted not to debate the bill and it wasn't considered. So, even though there was a majority who would vote the bill down, those opposed to the bill didn't want to risk a public debate on the merits of it. And they had the gall to do it when the students who survived the shooting were in attendance.
But, not to despair, the legislature did vote for a bill to declare pornography a public health risk.
That's Florida for you. Where boobies are bad but guns are good. In other words, in Florida, the 2nd Amendment trumps all.
Monday, February 19, 2018
The Gun Show
WNYC began producing a podcast entitled More Perfect in 2016. It is an exploration into the Supreme Court.
Last October they did an episode called "The Gun Show" about the history of 2nd amendment jurisprudence. I recommend it highly.
You will find that our modern day interpretation of the 2nd amendment is a fairly recent phenomenon.
Afterwards, ask yourself why the 2nd amendment is treated as sacrosanct while the 4th amendment is treated as an inconvenience.
Last October they did an episode called "The Gun Show" about the history of 2nd amendment jurisprudence. I recommend it highly.
You will find that our modern day interpretation of the 2nd amendment is a fairly recent phenomenon.
Afterwards, ask yourself why the 2nd amendment is treated as sacrosanct while the 4th amendment is treated as an inconvenience.
Wednesday, June 22, 2016
Why is two greater than four?
Why are we so concerned about the possibility that the Second Amendment might be restricted by legislation but we show no concern when the Nine (now Eight) Wearing Robes carve out restrictions to the Fourth, Fifth and Sixth Amendments?
This topic is nothing new to readers of this blog but, given the massacre in Orlando, it's timely once again.
Now the first thing we can do is forget about these ideas floating around that if you are on the government's "No Fly" list you shouldn't be able to buy a gun. There are no concrete criteria for being placed on that list. No one notifies you if you are placed on that list. There is no criteria for removing yourself from that list. Sure, "No fly, no buy" has a nice ring to it - but it's a nonstarter.
Besides, how many of the folks who carried out mass shootings in this country over the last decade were suspected terrorists? Would such a measure have stopped any one of those shootings? Highly doubtful. But it would allow politicians to say they did something in response to Orlando.
As I have said before, what we really need to do is address the gun culture in this country. And we can't do that without addressing racism. As the old white guard have found their numbers decreasing (and their influence over politics receding), the worship of the Second Amendment has become louder.
I suspect the reason such a stink is made over the Second Amendment is because those who held sway for so long because of the color of their skin know that the days of white power in the United States are coming to an end. They have some delusion that by holding onto their guns they can forestall the inevitable.
They like to trot out the trope that an unarmed populace is at the mercy of its government. Let's look at that for a second. The US government has nuclear weapons, "smart bombs," jets, helicopters, ships and an arsenal of deadly machine guns and other arms at its disposal. Do you really think your shotguns, semi-automatic rifles and .45s stand a chance? Stop being deluded by Red Dawn.
You say you're worried about the slippery slope that gun regulation might bring about? What about the shredding of the Fourth Amendment? Or are you not worried about that because it only protects "them."
And that's what this is really all about.
One day you will wake up to find the Fourth Amendment is gone. But then we'll still have the Second Amendment. Some comfort that will be.
Saturday, January 19, 2013
Rick Perry's praying for you
“As a free people, let us choose what kind of people we will be. Laws, the only redoubt of secularism, will not suffice. Let us all return to our places of worship and pray for help. Above all, let us pray for our children.” -- Texas Gov. Rick PerryGov. Rick Perry is upset. He's mighty upset that President Obama has proposed restrictions on the ability of anyone to buy a gun.
According to Mr. Perry, the actions announced by the White House the other day are a direct assault on the Second Amendment. And we certainly can't have that now, can we.
“In fact, the piling on by the political left, and their cohorts in the media, to use the massacre of little children to advance a pre-existing political agenda that would not have saved those children, disgusts me, personally,” the governor said. “The Second Amendment to the Constitution is a basic right of free people and cannot be nor will it be abridged by the executive power of this or any other president.”But where is out great defender of the Bill of Rights when it comes to shredding the Fourth Amendment? Where was Rick Perry when local jurisdictions decided to impose "No Refusal Weekends" on the driving public? Where was Rick Perry when motorists were threatened with forcible blood draws if they refused to blow into the breath test machine? Where was he when judges began accepting officers' sworn statements over the phone?
It's quite ironic that the gun lobby screams to the high heavens that any restriction on the ability of anyone to buy any weapon is a direct assault on the Second Amendment, but no on bats an eye as the courts and the legislature continue to eviscerate our protection against unreasonable search and seizure. Restrictions on gun sales or mandatory background checks won't affect all of us but weakening the Fourth Amendment makes it harder for us to exercise our right to be left alone.
Rick Perry is a buffoon. Anyone who witnessed his performance during his aborted Presidential run knows that. The idea that we're going to solve our addiction to violence by getting down on our knees and praying is absurd. Doesn't Rick Perry know that more people have been killed in the name of religion than for any other reason?
But then it's easier to exhort folks to prayer and to throw firebombs at political adversaries than it is to come up with a proposed solution of your own. Now I'm not naive. The measures proposed by President Obama won't prevent another massacre from happening. Enforcing the gun laws we already have on the books won't do it either. Even with stricter gun laws, there will be guns available for those who want them.
The answer to the problem of too many guns on the streets is not to put more guns out on the streets. That will only lead to more bloodshed, more death and more grieving families.
In the meantime more politicians will grandstand about how they will refuse to allow the White House to destroy the Second Amendment by restricting gun sales but very few will stand up to defend the Fourth Amendment.
And without the Fourth Amendment, your right to keep and bear arms will be nothing but an empty promise.
Wednesday, December 26, 2012
Worth the paper it's printed on
A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed. -- 2nd AmendmentFor the most ardent gun rights advocates out there, the language of the 2nd Amendment is sacrosanct. Of course the qualifying clause before the comma is often brushed off as if it didn't exist.
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches andseizures , shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized. -- 4th Amendment
We look back now at the Constitution and Bill of Rights as the great blueprints of our nation. At the time the Constitution was adopted, however, there were a multitude of voices arguing that the plan laid out in that document would only serve to enslave farmers and other agrarian interests. That's why we have two house of Congress - one represented the voice of the people and other represented the voice of the states. It's the reason the Electoral College was created - to ensure that the voters of just a few of the larger states could dictate who served as president. (The irony, of course, is that we have just the opposite situation today where the voters of a few states hold the rest of the nation hostage on Election Day.)
The agrarian interests were not in favor of a strong centralized government. They believed that only favored the monied interests in the larger states. One thing they really feared was the creation of a federal army. The 2nd Amendment was designed to sway those critics by leaving the defense of the republic to the state militias.
And, in order to have state militias capable of defending the republic against an expected attack from the English, folks needed to have guns.
Now that we have a professional army, the original rationale for the 2nd Amendment no longer exists.
If one wants to argue that the words of the 2nd Amendment are absolute, I can only show you the words in the 4th Amendment as proof that nothing in the Bill of Rights is absolute.
The 4th Amendment, despite its clear prohibition against unreasonable search and seizure and the warrant requirement has been honored far more in the breach than in the observance over the history of the republic. Most of the "reinterpretation" of the 4th Amendment has been the result of judges seeing cases in which someone either did something bad or had something bad and, but for a warrantless search, would have gotten away. Supreme Court justices, instead of reading the 4th Amendment and applying its words, adopted a results-oriented approach and looked for ways to get around the warrant requirement.
Over the years the Court has redefined "persons, houses, papers and effects" and created a mythical "reasonable expectation of privacy" test out of whole cloth. Courts have redefined "searches" and "seizures" in such a way that a person can be handcuffed in the back of a police car and not be considered seized and a pat down for weapons isn't considered a search. The word "unreasonable" has apparently been deleted from the English language and probable cause has become so watered down that stops are justified because an officer thinks someone may have violated the law.
Once upon a time we had a right to be left alone by the state, today you can get tased if you don't stop to answer questions.
Maybe it helps that gun holders and makers have a very powerful lobby behind them with lots of money to throw around while victims of warrantless searches tend to be convicted criminals without a lot of cash.
Thursday, September 24, 2009
The marketing of fear
According to this piece in the Houston Chronicle, gun dealers and ammunition makers have been doing lights-out business marketing to the right wing's fear that the Obama administration will make it harder for citizens to exercise their second amendment rights.
The fear-mongers only serve to make all gun owners look like clowns and wingnuts.
Jason Gregory, who manages Gretna Gun Works just outside of New Orleans, has been building his personal supply of ammunition for months. His goal is to have at least 1,000 rounds for each of his 25 weapons.“I call it the Obama effect,” said Gregory, 37, of Terrytown, La. “It always happens when the Democrats get in office. It happened with Clinton and Obama is even stronger for gun control. Ammunition will be the first step, so I’m stocking up while I can.”
The real clash isn't between the right and the left on this issue. What we're really witnessing is a clash between two ways of life -- rural and urban. Traditionally gun ownership has been highest in the rural parts of the country; after all, it's hard to hunt deer inside the Loop. As these rural areas become suburbanized, and as the younger folks move to more urban areas, the impetus to own guns diminishes.
This cultural gap also manifests itself in the longing for "the good ol' days." The same "good ol' days" that brought us "separate, but not equal," Jim Crow and glass ceilings.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)